AG-2024.06-151·astro-ph.HE·cross-listed: gr-qc
Cosmic Censorship in Sgr A* and M87*: Observationally Excluding Naked Singularities
Authors
- Avery E. Broderick
- Kiana Salehi
Abstract
The imaging of Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*) and the supermassive black hole at the center of Messier 87 (M87*) by the Event Horizon Telescope constrains the location and nature of emission from these objects. Coupled with flux limits from the near-infrared through the ultraviolet, the attendant size constraints provide strong evidence for the absence of an accretion-powered photosphere, and therefore for the existence of an event horizon about an astrophysical black hole. Here, we demonstrate that a broad class of naked singularities exhibit inner turning points for time-like geodesics, and therefore may generically be excluded, regardless of the nature and unknown physical impact of singularity itself, subject to the single weak assumption that the its nongravitational impact is localized to its immediate vicinity. While we restrict our attention to static, spherically symmetric spacetimes, we are nevertheless able to exclude or constrain a large number of commonly invoked naked singularity spacetimes in this way.
Submitted
7 June 20241 year ago
Version
v1
License
CC-BY-4.0
DOI
10.48550/arXiv.2406.05181
Summary
Using observations of black holes Sgr A* and M87* from the Event Horizon Telescope, researchers show that a wide class of naked singularities (exposed singularities without event horizons) would leave detectable signatures in light patterns that we don't actually observe, providing strong evidence that real black holes do have event horizons.
- The EHT images of two supermassive black holes show no evidence of the glowing surfaces that naked singularities would produce, ruling out many theoretical alternatives to normal black holes.
- The authors prove that naked singularities generically create inner turning points where particles can't get pulled further in—a feature that would create observable differences in how light behaves near these objects.
- This work bridges theory and observation: it shows that you don't need to fully understand what a singularity is to rule it out experimentally, just measure whether light behaves the way Einstein's equations predict for a normal black hole.
curious · generated by claude-haiku-4-5
Chat with this PDF
Ask questions, probe assumptions, request a plain-English summary. Answers cite sections from the preprint itself.
Community
Questions and answers about this paper from other readers. No formal peer review — just a place to think out loud.